St. Elmo Steak House
- from USD 30
- Ideal for a special occasion
Sign up free — See who's going and message them.
About
Menu & prices
More photos 7
1 / 7
Sphilbrick · CC BY-SA 3.0 · edited
Why go
- Four jumbo shrimp with the house’s fiery signature cocktail sauce.
- A 32-ounce USDA Prime Tom-A-Hawk ribeye aged for 60 days.
- A basement wine cellar holding 20,000 bottles, including a 1902 Château Lafite Rothschild.
- An America’s Classics award from the James Beard Foundation.
Opening hours
Today16:00 – 22:00Show all
Good to know
Dishes to try
- Traditional starter options: navy bean soup or Red Gold tomato juice
- Steak entrées with a choice of potato, fries or green beans
- 28-ounce bone-in porterhouse
- Amish chicken
- King crab mac ’n’ cheese
- Wedge salad
- Spinach salad with Indiana goat cheese from Caprini Creamery
- Locally sourced Viking Lamb rack with chateaubriand sauce and mashed potatoes
- Sliders, carpaccio and calamari on the separate menu at the upstairs 1933 Lounge and downstairs bar
- House-made chocolate cake
- New York-style cheesecake
- Crème brûlée made with Madagascar vanilla beans
Booking a table
- Book a table through the restaurant’s website.
- The main dining room, also called the entry room, is available by reservation.
Atmosphere
- Celebrity photographs, racing stars, artwork and memorabilia cover the original restaurant’s walls.
- The original tiger-oak bar survives, while a window-side prep chef lets diners watch shrimp cocktails, seafood and steaks being prepared.
- The restaurant offers private dining and live music.
Dietary options
- Vegan Vegan, gluten-free and other dietary requests can be accommodated when possible. Call +1 317-635-0636 ahead to discuss your requirements.
History
Joe Stahr named the restaurant after Erasmus of Formia, also known as St. Elmo, the patron saint of sailors. Its original menu offered shrimp cocktail for 10 cents; the dish still uses the same horseradish sauce.
- 1902Joe Stahr opened the restaurant in Braden’s Block as a saloon serving travelers from Union Station and nearby wholesalers. It has remained in the building since it began.
- 1947Harry Roth took over the restaurant and later partnered with Izzy Rosen.
- 1970sThe restaurant expanded into the neighboring Reinhardt and Louis G. Deschler Company buildings.
- 1982The buildings became part of the Indianapolis Union Station-Wholesale District historic district on the National Register.
- 1986Steve Huse bought the restaurant from Harry Roth and Izzy Rosen and brought his son Craig into the family business.
Show all
- 2011A renovation added the second-floor 1933 Lounge, named for the year Prohibition ended.
- 2012The restaurant began bottling its signature sauce for sale through regional grocers.
- 2018Joey Chestnut ate 18 lb 9.6 oz of shrimp cocktail in eight minutes at the restaurant’s contest, setting a world record.
Accessibility
- Parking Valet parking is available.
- Wheelchair access The restaurant is wheelchair accessible.
Sources: St. Elmo Steak House - Wikipedia · Indianapolis - Wikivoyage (eat) · St. Elmo Steak House: Legendary Since 1902 · Menus | St. Elmos Steak House in Indianapolis, … · St. Elmo History | St. Elmos Steak House in Ind… · checked 29 Sep 2026
- Website
- stelmos.com/
- Phone
- +13176350636
Questions and answers
Where is St. Elmo Steak House?
127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, Indiana.
Where can I check dinner prices?
See the restaurant’s current menu: https://www.stelmos.com/menus/
What are St. Elmo Steak House’s opening hours?
Monday–Thursday 16:00–22:00; Friday 16:00–23:00; Saturday 15:00–23:00; Sunday 16:00–21:00.
Does St. Elmo Steak House offer private dining?
Yes, private dining is available.
Is there live music at St. Elmo Steak House?
Yes, live music is offered.
Can I order St. Elmo Steak House products for home delivery?
Yes, sauces, seasonings and steaks are available for home delivery.
- See who's going — faces, not ticket counts.
- Write to someone who shares your interests — no swipes, no matches, no paywall.
- Pick the event or the place to meet at — and go together.









